In my initial review of the book, I promised to try out at least a pattern or two. I thought it was only fair. So, I present to you the Balthazar Vest. Warm, thick and a bit bulky....ahem.
One thing I absolutely love about blogging is all the positive energy and encouraging words I get from you. This is why I need to ask of something different today. I need brutal honesty here (not that your not normally honest, I really believe you are). Give it to me straight though. You know, as if you were my sister...tell me I look like a sausage, if that's what you think. Would you giggle a little if you saw me walking down the street? Does it look ridiculous?
The total measurements came out to be about 29 inches around - that large chest opening in the front helps a whole lot when trying to squeeze into this tiny thing. I'm about 34 inches around which means that this poor little guy was required to stretch to be 5 inches bigger, and I'm pretty sure I heard the stitches scream in pain as I was pulling it over my head.
Pattern: Balthazar Vest from Twinkle's Big City Knits by Wenlan Chia.
Needles: Size 17 Crystal Palace Bamboo 24" circluars. This was the first time I've used these redesigned needles and loved them. They have smooth connectors that swivle about to avoid wire twisting. I also used Size 15 short Bamboo circulars by Clover.
Time to Knit: 1 weekend.
Yarn: 5 hanks of Blue Sky Alpaca's Bulky Hand-dyes in Teal, color # 1011. This is the second time I've used this stuff and continue to love it. Although, as I said before, it comes at a hefty price for a mere 45 yards per hank. The look and feel of this fiber is worth every bit of the 85 some odd dollars it cost. The Web's discount helps too. I used exactly 5 hanks = 225 yards with about 1 inch to spare (yes, I needed a drink afterwards, the final hours were pretty stressful). The pattern calls for 220 yards of super bulky wool for all sizes. There is absolutely no way that one could knit this in the M and L sizes with just 220 yards of super bluky yarn.
Modifications: The pattern calls for all the ribbing to be done in size 16 needles. I did the waist ribbing in the standard size 17, because I knew it was already going to a tight fit (ooh, and also, because I forgot to start with the small needles...but we'll just pretend for the sake of my ego that I did that on purpose). I knit the shoulder caps on size 15 circulars, and the neck band on size 17's which also worked out nicely. The pattern called for picking up 34 stitches around the neck band. I only picked up 26 because that's what made the most sense when I was doing it and I needed as much support as I could get to pull this thing in tight around my bust. I'm glad I did it this way, because it provides a lot more shape, I think.
Errata: The published errata (pdf) is incomplete and only talks about yarn requirements (which is still incorrect).
I found quite a few mistakes, here they are if your planning on knitting this. If your not, just scroll down and critisize the pictures (I'm kidding, I'm kidding!!):
BACK: With RS facing, BO 2 sts, knit 16 (18, 20, 22), BO 2 sts....
SLEEVE CAP: With RS facing, starting from armpit, with smaller needles...
NECKBAND: Row 1: *K1, p1; rep from *. Work 5 more rows in K1, P1 rib as established.
Notes: The pattern is an interesting design, but very poorly written. It's vague and assumes too much. For example, it doesn't help you along to make sure that your keeping the eyelet detail along the sides. And the neck band, ooh the neck band. It just tells you to pick up the stitches and rib, providing no direction on how to create that criss cross detailing in the front.
All in all, I give this pattern a 5 out of 10 for being cute, but messy and poorly written. I'm having trouble letting this book go though, because the designs are so chic. I think it might be better served as a coffee table eye-candy type of book for friends to flip through when visiting, rather then something functional. Which, I guess is consistant with the runway in general. Interesting to look at, impractical to wear.